Case Study

NFC Enabled Touch Panel

Project Overview

The Extron TouchLink Pro touch panels give users easy and complete control over the connected devices in a meeting room or larger space. This R&D project focused on adding NFC chips to the panels and the experience of interacting with the new functionality.

 

Role

UX Designer (2021-2022)
User Research, Interaction, Prototyping, Visual Design

👋 Quick Introductions

TouchLink Pro

The TouchLink Pro comes in many shapes and sizes and is the end user-facing interface for controlling the technology in a room. These touch panels are designed to control video, audio, lighting, shades, HVAC, security, and other systems within virtually any environment.

“Mach” Template Examples

  • We have designed and tested multiple templates for our TLPs over the years

  • In addition to the templates, we have also created a guide for users who want or need to design their own interface

Touch panels range from 3”-17” and can be table-top, wall-mounted, or installed into a recessed cubby

Wide TLP on a lectern, coordinating and controlling various inputs for a presentation

 

Additional screens and sizes:

Following a mobile-first approach, we prioritized the most important content on smaller screens


NFC Technology

Near-field communication (NFC) enables data sharing between an NFC tag and an electronic device over a small distance (approx. 4cm).

A “tap” or scan between an NFC tag and an NFC-enabled device can facilitate:

  • contactless payment

  • unlocking and starting your vehicle

  • opening doors touch-free

  • connecting electronic devices to share data


 

📌 The Problem (aka the Opportunity)

  • Over the years, many of our customers have asked for touch-free solutions for accessing and controlling work spaces

  • Touch-free usually means faster, and when done well, can also mean seamless

  • Post-pandemic, there is also a looming safety concern about limiting the spread of harmful germs

💡We have explored several possible touch-free solutions, including voice user interface, QR codes and NFC compatibility. This research and development project was an exploration into Extron + NFC.

Additional Context 👀

  • PD, UX and ENG collaborated over the course of a few weeks to develop this POC


 

Empathize and Define

Touch panels are used in many different environments, by a wide variety of people. While voice commands and QR codes are becoming more widely adopted, NFC technology is still relatively unknown.

READ: We needed to make this new workflow as obvious and intuitive as possible.

Research

📝 User Goals

  • Convenient and quick access

  • Touch-free entry to secure buildings and rooms

  • Easily share and apply user preferences

😥 Painpoints

  • An earlier touch panel experiment had a UFC chip embedded into the beveled edge on one side

  • This model had a VERY small NFC logo which indicated the scannable area

  • If a person does not see this tiny logo, or does not recognize the logo and its purpose, they will be left guessing as to what to do

    Example:

This is a representation of what the original hardware model looked like; the logo on the actual device was much smaller and had less contrast

Secondary Research

Examples

GOOD: This Sony ball speaker has a tiny NFC logo to indicate the scannable area, but at least it is in an obvious spot

 

BETTER: Both of these printers have a backlit icon to indicate the scannable area

 

BEST: Both of these examples give users onscreen directions 😎

 

Ideate & Prototype

We practiced Lean UX to quickly generate ideas and concepts with very few requirements. Working under tight deadlines, we performed quick, guerilla-style usability testing and incorporated the qualitative feedback into our iterative process.

1st Iteration

  • Based on feedback from SME’s and competitive analysis, we recommended putting the NFC chip “under the glass”, and that we build the workflow into the UI

  • Our first concept added the step of scanning an NFC chip to an existing start screen:

👎 Findings

  • This required disabling the main content until users have been authenticated, complicating the design and creating the opportunity for user confusion

 

2nd Iteration

This time we added a new screen, solely for scanning the NFC chip:

👍 Findings

  • This flow gives users clear instruction on how to proceed

  • It also distinguishes the act of of scanning from first step of using the panel to control a space

Hi(ish) Fidelity

With buy-in from Product Management and Engineering, we moved forward with the second iteration.

  • I created a very basic prototype, to get feedback on the workflow

What’s Next?

📊 Usability Testing

🔄 More Iteration

 

Because of nationwide component shortages, this project has been deprioritized. I am not sure when we will pick it back up.

This R&D project was fast and fun, but the design needs further testing and iteration before it is ready to ship.